"In 2003,
Columbia Business School professor Frank Flynn and New York University
professor Cameron Anderson ran an experiment to test perceptions of men and
women in the workplace. They started with a Harvard Business School case study
about a real-life entrepreneur named Heidi Roizen. The case described how
Roizen became a successful venture capitalist by using her "outgoing
personality...and vast persona and professional network [that] included many of
the most powerful business leaders in the technology sector." Flynn and
Anderson assigned half of the students to read Heidi's story and gave the other
half the same story with just one difference-- they changed the name
"Heidi" to "Howard."
The professors polled students about their impressions of Heidi
and Howard. The students rated Heidi and Howard as equally competent, which
made sense since "their" accomplishments were completely identical.
Yet while students respected both Heidi and Howard, Howard came across as a
more appealing colleague. Heidi, was seen as selfish and not "the type of
person you want to hire or work for." The same data with a single
difference- gender- created vastly different impressions.
This experiment supports what research has already clearly show:
success and likeability are positively correlated for men and negatively
correlated for women. When a man is successful, his is liked by both men and
women. When a woman is successful, people of both genders like her less. This
truth is both shocking and unsurprising: shocking because no one would ever
admit to stereotyping on the basis of gender and unsurprising because we
clearly do.
Decades of social sciences studies have confirmed what the
Heidi/Howard case study so blatantly demonstrates: we evaluate people based on stereotypes.
Our stereotype of men holds that they are providers, decisive, and driven. Our
stereotype of women holds that they are caregivers, sensitive, and communal.
Because we characterize men and women in opposition to each other, professional
achievement and all the traits associated with it get placed in the male
column. By focusing on her career and taking a calculated approach to amassing
power, Heidi violated our stereotypical expectations of women. Yet by behaving
in the exact same manner, Howard lived up to our stereotypical expectations of
men. The end result? Liked him, disliked her."
No comments:
Post a Comment