Saturday, March 8, 2014

Staying home with children vs working?

There is a myth of mothers who work who are able to "do it all," which is impossible to attain. More from the Lean In book talking about studies dealing with this. I love it since this means I don't have to go do my own research later. It is tough for mothers to make the choice between spending more in their careers versus at home with the children.

"In 1991, the Early Child Care Research Network, under the auspices of the National Institue of Child Health and Human Development, initiated the most ambitious and comprehensive study to date on the relationship between child care and child development, and in particular on the effect of exclusive maternal care versus child care. The Research Network, which comprised more than 30 child care development experts from leading universities across the country, spent 18 months designing the study. They tracked more than 1,000 children over 15 years, repeatedly assessing the children's cognitive skills, language abilities, and social behaviors. Dozens of papers have been published about what they found.

In 2006, researchers released a report summarizing their findings, which concluded that "children who were cared for exclusively by their mothers did not develop differently than those who were also cared for by others. They found no gap in cognitive skills, language competence, social competence, ability to build and maintain relationships, or in the quality of the mother-child bond. Parental behavioral factor-- including fathers who are responsive and positive, mothers who favor "self-directed child behavior," and parents with emotional intimacy in their marriages-- influence a child's development 2-3x more than any form of child care. Exclusive maternal care was not related to better or worse outcomes for children. There is, thus, no reason for mothers to feel as though they are harming their children if they decide to work."

Children absolutely need parental involvement, love, care, time, and attention. But parents who work outside the home are still capable of giving their children a loving and secure childhood. Some data even suggest that having 2 parents working outside the home can be advantageous to a child's development, particularly for girls.

Guilt management can be just as important as time management for mothers. When I went back to my job after giving birth, other working mothers told me to prepare for the day that my son would cry for his nanny. Sure enough, when he was about 11 months old, he was crawling on the floor of his room of his room and put his knee down on a toy. He looked up for help, crying, and reached for her instead of me. It pierced my heart, but Dave [husband] thought it was a good sign- forming an attachment to a caregiver was good for his development. I understood his logic, especially in retrospect, but at the time, it hurt like hell.

Far from worrying about nights he misses, Dave thinks we are heroes for getting home for dinner as often as we do. Our different viewpoints seems inextricably gender based. Compared to his peers, Dave is an exceptionally devoted dad. Compared to many of my peers, I spend a lot more time away from my children.

Stanford professor Jennifer Aaker's work shows that setting obtainable goals is key to happiness. Instead of perfection, we should aim for sustainable and fulfilling. The right question is not "Can I do it all?" but "Can I do what's most important for me and my family?"



Personally, my pull for spending time at home is not as much as the guilt factor but just wanting to be there all the time in my future children's lives. I do want to work part time at least, which will also be good for my children, but hearing what the research shows is reassuring.

No comments:

Post a Comment